The Gist: FF's Large Adult Son

The Minister for Justice ends November with High Court findings of illogical actions and wrongful assertions. This is the Gist.

Share
The Gist: FF's Large Adult Son
Photo by Fer Troulik / Unsplash

We've been talking about Jim O'Callaghan more than is either healthy or desirable for a happy life in the last few months' Gists. The Minister for Justice has been urgently trying to make a name for himself before his leadership Best Before date expires.

To that end, we have seen him announcing immigration restrictions and an ongoing refusal to issue student visas to Gazans (see The Gist: What if) as well as his ongoing fight with solicitors working on legal aid defence to impose a flat fee for cases, no matter how many court visits they might need to make (see The Gist: The Petty Bourgeoisie).

Neither policy was defended with any coherent argument in public, as is his habit. Instead, he asserted he was going to do it and then refused to move from that position in the face of people pointing out why he ought not.

Euclid’s Nightmare: The Lumpy Flat

On the solicitor's fees plan he was supported by loud voices in editorial and pol corr end of the print media who framed his plan in the context of the strength it showed he would bring as a party leadership candidate.

All of which suddenly changed after the High Court issued a decision on the 3rd November saying;

"Key elements of the controversial new criminal legal aid payment model for the District Courts are “grossly unfair”, “illogical” and in excess of the powers of the Minister for Justice under the legal aid Act".

Within days the Minister met the Law Society and did a deal. And everyone who had previously been buying JimStock in anticipation of his leadership IPO worked hard to present that deal as anything other than a comical loss of face. I'm going to quote the Department's press release directly, which was reproduced without counterpoint everywhere on its announcement.

"The District Court flat fee payment structure remains and there will no longer be multiple certs granted for separate and distinct cases.
There will be enhanced payments made under the flat fee structure for separate and distinct cases involving two or more charges which are brought on the same day.
There will also be an enhanced single flat fee payment for cases which are often elongated."

The key point of the dispute was that there was going to be a flat fee for solicitors and he wouldn't pay any more. This being the definition of a flat fee.

But now the Minister has introduced a new kind of flat fee. In this one, you get a flat fee but also, sometimes, you get paid more.

Whatever gets the Minister through the night, the Law Society might say, as he explained that this geometrically-unique lumpy flat fee is still the same thing he was always looking for (and doesn't address the High Court's findings of ultra vires).

Dril tweet screenshot: Post wint on X: ""im not owned! im not owned!!", i continue to insist as i slowly shrink and transform into a corn cob" Conversation      @dril     wint     @dril     "im not owned!  im not owned!!", i continue to insist as i slowly shrink and transform into a corn cob

The War on Learning

Of course this was not the Minister's only set piece battle. Let's not forget his courageous efforts to stop talented young people from Gaza from studying in Irish universities.

Well, in the same week the High Court declared he was acting illogically and unlawfully in his actions against solicitors, a different High Court judge was also addressing his Gaza student visa actions. As the court report led with;

The High Court has overturned a decision to deny an Irish visa to a 20-year-old Palestinian woman seeking to pursue a university scholarship here, after the court held that there were “significant and demonstrable errors” in the refusal...
The judge’s ruling arises from admissions that the Minister wrongly asserted Abudalu had not provided certain financial documentation in her visa application, and that certification Abudalu provided relating to her proficiency in English had not been considered by the application decision-maker. The latter came to light on the second day of the trial of the case.

Here, after the student's lawyers challenged it on day one of the trial, the Minister admitted that key assertions he had made to the court were simply not true.

The Department of Justice has previously said it would take into 2027 to review the file anyway. But behold! after the ruling against the Minister, the case was listed a month later and it turned out that, when they looked at them, they were able to grant 48 visas (and counting), just like that.

The students may have lost the beginning of their studies. The Minister lost something rather more precious to him.

All of the JimStock holders have studiously avoided addressing this month of collapsing positions, findings of unlawful action and illogical policy-making from the courts in the aid of personal ambition.

Whether that pained silence will continue after Michael Martin batted away the assumtion he was planning to resign and instead confirmed he intended to lead the party into the next election remains to be seen. The Big Man of Justice may have spent this month passing through his Best Before date. Presuming Martin means what he says, he'll need to do something he has failed to do up until now to get the leadership job.

He'll have to make an argument for why he ought to get it before he passes his Use By date. And if this month has shown one thing, it is that making arguments that can stand up to challenge is not the Minister's strong suit.